Through The Eyes of a Woman
Re'eh: The Laws of Kosher Animals
In this parshah, the Torah goes through the different animals, fish and
birds, and gives us signs to tell us which of the many species of creatures we may
and may not eat.
As far as four-legged animals are concerned, the Torah gives a very simple sign:
Those animals that chew their cud and have split hooves, you may eat; those that
have only one, or neither of these signs, are forbidden for you to eat.
Until we learn a little Chabad Chassidus, we just take this as a matter
of fact: HaShem created thousands of kinds of animals, and in a small minority
of them HaShem created these two signs, and we don't think more of it. However,
the Rebbe points out that nothing HaShem did is simply coincidental. In other
words, if HaShem chose these two specific signs to be the differentiation
between kosher and non-kosher animals, it cannot be a coincidence; there has to
be a specific reason why it is these signs, and not others. For example,
HaShem could have made all kosher animals with a red stripe around their
necks, or any of an infinite number of possible signs to make those animals look
different from non-kosher animals. Why specifically these two signs, chewing
the cud and having split hooves?
You might argue that these signs are not significant in themselves; they are
only indications of the kashrus of these animals, not causes
of their being kosher, and are therefore not directly related to the fact that they
are kosher. Nevertheless, nothing is by coincidence, and as the Baal Shem Tov taught,
anything which you witness should teach you a lesson in serving HaShem. Therefore,
we must explain what the horaah is that we can learn from chewing the cud
and having split hooves.
People, in a sense, are also animals. By this I do not mean to suggest that I
hold by Darwin's evolutionary theory, that a person is just a descendant of the
ape. Instead, I mean to say that there are certain things we have in common with
animals -- certain ways of behavior, certain needs, certain drives. We
are animals that have to serve HaShem, but within us we have the animal soul,
the nefesh habahamis, mentioned in the first chapter of Tanya.
We cannot go through life without eating, drinking, sleeping, and doing other things
that animals do. Nevertheless, there are ways that a Jew can elevate his life so
that he becomes a kosher animal. In other words, everyone on earth has to
live a more or less physical life, as a soul within a physical body. However, there
are kosher and non-kosher ways of living. As Torah Jews, we want to know how we,
together with our animal-like bodies, should live in a way that makes us kosher
animals, rather than unkosher animals. The Rebbe uses the signs that differentiate
kosher from non-kosher animals to explain how we, as human beings with an animal
side to us, must live in order to be categorized as kosher animals.
We all know that there are people whom we consider animals, because there is
no spirituality in their lives; we see in their lives only physical desires and
motivations. What are the motivations of an animal? An animal is driven by a desire
for food, to reproduce, to look out for itself. An animal is motivated by instincts,
rather than by reasoned intellect, or by principles. When a person lives in the
same way, driven by his animal instincts and passions, we say the person is like
an animal. Nevertheless, these things are part of life, and we have to live our
life partially on a physical plane and partially on a spiritual plane. The Rebbe
explains that for this reason HaShem has given two signs which differentiate
between kosher and non-kosher animals. These signs are guides by which we can try
to keep our lives on a level that will make us kosher, and even holy, unlike other
people who do not live their lives by these signs.
All non-kosher animals have either a round hoof, where there is no division at all,
like a horse, or toes with more than two divisions, like the paws of dogs and cats.
Kosher animals, by contrast, have split hooves, with two sides to the hoof and a
gap between them.
The Rebbe explains this as follows: A person is born with certain
inborn natural tendencies, which are not the result of education or environment.
We can see these even in the smallest infants and young children. Some people are
naturally gentle; others are naturally aggressive; some people gravitate toward
one kind of activity, while others gravitate toward a completely different kind
If a person spends his life totally devoted to the things that come naturally
to him, this is not called serving HaShem. It is serving oneself. In other
words, suppose that by nature you find a certain way appealing, comfortable, and
easy for you, and you never deviate from it your whole life. You remain with what
is comfortable and easy. Then you've never risen above what is natural, you have
made no effort to transcend your natural self.
In the sixties and seventies there were people, and even entire movements, that
set themselves the goal of being natural, of living like animals. "That is pure,"
they taught, "that is holiness." If you can just walk around with a loincloth, eat
raw food, drink water out of your hand, and live by your animal passions and instincts,
then you have achieved perfection. Yiddishkeit, however, teaches that you
have to transcend your natural, animal self. If you do not do this you are not serving
HaShem; you're locked into a certain natural inborn pattern, like an animal.
An animal could never rise above its nature. A cow, for example, could never become
more than a cow. For its entire life, a cow is motivated by things that motivate
cows; it could never do more than that, and it could never change itself to become
more than a cow. When did you last see a cow sitting down and looking up at the
sky, wondering why HaShem created it? Tigers are different from cows. A tiger
lives its life totally motivated by those tendencies that motivate tigers, and it
could never become a cow. A tiger will never act like a cow, nor will a cow act
like a tiger; each spends its life doing the things that come naturally to that
How do you become a kosher animal? By rising above your innate nature, by transcending
the way you were born. Sometimes, you have to do things which do not come naturally
to you, and even things that might be the opposite of your nature -- because
HaShem said so. This a cow cannot do, nor can a tiger. This is what is symbolized
by the split hooves. They indicate that there are two paths -- the left
path and the right path. There are times in a person's life when HaShem says
you have to exhibit strength. A person might say, "But I'm not that kind of person.
I'm a gentle soul. To exert force is against my character." However, one ought to
say, "I know it's against my character, and it's hard for me to say or do things
like this. But HaShem told me to do it, so I have to overpower my natural
tendency to go to the right, which is chessed, kindness, and go to the left."
By doing this one rises above one's natural tendencies, and one becomes a "kosher
In other words, the prerequisite for being kosher is the ability to go in both
directions, right and left, as HaShem demands. To do what is comfortable
for you, and ignore what is difficult for you, is not going to change you at all.
For example: Avraham Avinu (our father Abraham) was the epitome of love and
kindness, as the verse states, "Give... chessed (kindness) to Avraham." In
order to prove to the world that Avraham's chessed was not simply the result
of his natural tendencies, but was his way of serving HaShem, he was
put through a test, where he was required to display the utmost degree of harshness
-- he was commanded by G-d to slaughter his beloved son, Yitzchak, for
whom he had waited for so many years. When he showed his willingness to carry out
G-d's command, even though at the last minute the decree was annulled, the Torah
states that now it is known that Abraham fears G-d. Since he was able to
transcend his natural tendency towards love and kindness, he proved that what motivated
him was not his natural characteristics but a love of HaShem. When
a person loves HaShem, he can transcend his nature and do the opposite of
what comes easily to him.
Similarly, there are certain mitzvos that some people find easy to do,
and other mitzvos that they find difficult to do. Serving HaShem means
doing them all -- those that are agreeable to you, and those that are
disagreeable to you, those that seem to be against your nature. I say "seem to be,"
because the real nature of a Jew is that he wants to fulfill G-d's will, no matter
what this entails. Therefore, there is nothing which is really against his nature.
It only seems that way.
Thus, the split hooves teach us the necessity of going in whichever direction
HaShem asks, whether it is easy or not.
What does this sign teach us? During a person's life he must make decisions that
are difficult, because life is truly complex, with many, many factors that could
color his decision. For example, at times we have to make a decision that does not
come easily to us. When we face such a situation, we often base the decision on
what is the most comfortable, or what will make the least waves in our lifestyle.
However, that is not necessarily always the correct decision. Let's say that the
issue is about moving, about whether we should leave our neighborhood. This is a
situation that happens to many people. You live in a certain neighborhood where
you have a nice house, you have friends, and you're all settled. Everything is fine
and comfortable. But you are beginning to realize that there are certain factors
in this environment that are not good for your family or for yourself. Just the
thought of uprooting and changing your whole lifestyle, changing your apartment
and your job, is so difficult that often you might say, "Oh, it's not so bad, you
know. I'll just stay here." It could be, however, that the right decision is to
do the difficult thing. Of course, this decision-making process might apply to many
aspects of life, to a shidduch, for example, or to the chinuch (education)
of children, which can involve very, very difficult decisions for parents to make.
Because of all these difficulties, we cannot make decisions capriciously, or at
the snap of a finger. That, the Rebbe says, is the horaah we learn from chewing
the cud. To be a kosher animal, a Jew must know that he should talk things over
with other people, and think things over a few times, especially in situations and
decisions that involve Torah and Yiddishkeit. A kosher animal doesn't just
gulp the food down; it chews it over and over and over again. Similarly, a Jew who
is serious about his Yiddishkeit is going to be serious about the decisions
in his life that involve Yiddishkeit; this requires chewing the cud --
thinking about it over and over and over, from every angle. The Rebbe himself would
at times ask people to appoint somebody as a mashpia
with whom to discuss matters before coming to a decision. Do not just make a decision
based on what feels good, or on what is comfortable and easy. Talk it over with
an objective person, preferably one who has experience in life, and knows the Torah
and chassidic point of view. That person may see your life in a very different light
from the way you see it. He or she may help you make that difficult decision by
presenting options and situations in a way that will help you see what is right
to do, though it may be difficult for you. Just as kosher animals chew their food
over and over, we, too, must think about things over and over. We must make sure
that we've looked at a matter from all angles, and have chewed it well before we
make a decision. This way we will decide correctly, based on the right motivations
and the right reasons, and not just on the whim of the moment.
The attitude of
"What's the difference? It's all good. Everything happens by hashgachah peratis,"
is an incorrect attitude. Of course, everything is by hashgachah peratis,
but nevertheless, HaShem has given us the ability to make free choices, which
are not predetermined. Your choice is essentially free. Therefore, you have to be
very careful when you make a decision that might change the course of your life
or the lives of members of your family. Even a minor decision can greatly affect
the rest of your life. Think it over, talk it over, think it over again, and then
decide with the knowledge that you have looked at all the angles, and that you have
not decided rashly.